Heart-Rate Zones
When to update heart-rate zones: what changes as fitness improves
Heart-rate zones built on a percentage of maximum heart rate need updating far less often than most people expect. Training changes how much work a person can do at a given heart rate and moves the point where effort stops feeling steady. It changes maximum heart rate only slightly, if at all. A stored maximum should therefore change when there is credible evidence that it is wrong, not because sessions have started to feel easier. Progress shows up as more output in the same zone.
Three numbers that respond differently to training
Three separate numbers sit behind a zone display, and training affects each one differently.
- Maximum heart rate is the highest rate the heart reaches during an all-out effort. In a percentage-of-max system, every zone boundary is calculated from it.
- Submaximal heart rate is the heart rate at a fixed workload, such as rowing at a set pace or cycling at a set number of watts.
- Thresholds are the intensities at which breathing and blood lactate start to rise more steeply. Above the first one, steady talking becomes difficult. They mark the top of comfortable, sustainable work.
Maximum heart rate: mostly age, slightly training
Age explains most of the difference in maximum heart rate between adults. Tanaka and colleagues' 2001 meta-analysis of 351 studies and 18,712 people produced the estimate 208 − 0.7 × age, and habitual physical activity did not change that relationship. Those are differences between people. Gellish and colleagues (2007) looked within people instead. They analysed 908 maximal tests from 132 members of one university fitness centre, collected over 25 years, and arrived at almost the same slope, 207 − 0.7 × age. Maximum heart rate falls by about 0.7 beats per minute per year, roughly 3 to 4 beats over five years.
Training may shift the maximum a little. A 2000 review by Zavorsky of studies in sedentary adults and endurance athletes estimated that aerobic training can lower maximum heart rate by 3 to 7%, and that stopping training can raise it again. The author called the evidence limited and asked for cautious interpretation. The HERITAGE Family Study, which trained 507 previously sedentary adults on cycle ergometers for 20 weeks, found only a small decrease in heart rate at maximal exercise.
Submaximal heart rate shows progress
At the same workload, heart rate falls as fitness improves. In HERITAGE, heart rate while cycling at 50 watts was significantly lower after training, and resting heart rate dropped by 2.7 to 4.6 beats per minute depending on the group. Much of this comes from a larger stroke volume, the amount of blood the heart pumps with each beat. A heart that moves more blood per beat needs fewer beats for the same work.
On a zone display, the same row or ride now sits lower on the scale. A member who keeps working in Zone 3 after a training block is usually producing more pace or power there than before. The zones are still correct. The member is fitter.
Thresholds can move the most
Training also moves the thresholds, especially in people starting from a low level. Hurley and colleagues (1984) trained 8 men for 12 weeks, and their VO₂max, the maximum rate at which the body can take up and use oxygen, rose by 26%. Before training, blood lactate reached 2.5 millimoles per litre at 68% of VO₂max. After training, it took 75%. Londeree's 1997 meta-analysis of 34 studies found large threshold gains in previously sedentary participants and smaller, statistically nonsignificant gains in people who were already trained.
Both measured thresholds as oxygen uptake, not heart rate. A threshold at a higher share of VO₂max does not automatically sit at a higher share of maximum heart rate. In HERITAGE, heart rate after training was lower even at the same share of VO₂max, which pulls in the opposite direction. What is clear is that a newer member can sustain more work before reaching the threshold. Where the threshold now falls on the zone scale has to be checked directly, while the stored maximum can stay as it is.
Telling change from day-to-day noise
Heart rate at the same workload varies from day to day. Lamberts and colleagues (2004) had 44 young adults repeat the same submaximal running test at the same time of day on five consecutive days. In the most repeatable stage, at about 90% of maximum, heart rate still varied by an average of 5 beats per minute between days. The easier stages varied more. Outside a laboratory, sleep, heat, caffeine and hydration add to this.
One session that reads 5 beats higher or lower than usual says nothing reliable about fitness or maximum heart rate. A consistent difference across several sessions in similar conditions does.
Illustration: how far a smaller maximum moves the boundaries
This is a calculation, not a prediction for any individual. Pulz8 zones start at 60% (Zone 2), 70% (Zone 3), 80% (Zone 4) and 90% (Zone 5) of the stored maximum. The table shows the boundaries for a stored maximum of 185 and for maximums 3% and 7% lower, the range from Zavorsky's review.
| Zone starts at | Maximum 185 | Maximum 179 (3% lower) | Maximum 172 (7% lower) |
|---|---|---|---|
| Zone 2 (60%) | 111 | 107 | 103 |
| Zone 3 (70%) | 130 | 125 | 120 |
| Zone 4 (80%) | 148 | 143 | 138 |
| Zone 5 (90%) | 167 | 161 | 155 |
A 3% change moves each boundary by 4 to 6 beats, about the size of day-to-day variation. A 7% change moves them by 8 to 12 beats, enough to change the colour of a steady effort. Five years of ageing, about 3.5 beats off the maximum, moves them by 2 to 3 beats.
When to change the stored maximum
- A credible reading above it. A clean trace from a hard effort that exceeds the stored maximum shows the value is too low. The article on maximum heart rate explains how to judge whether a reading is credible.
- An age-based estimate that is several years old. Recalculating a formula-based maximum every few years keeps it in line with age. A measured maximum is better evidence than any formula.
- A medication change. Drugs such as beta-blockers lower heart rate during exercise. Intensity guidance should then come from the prescribing clinician, not from an adjusted number on a board.
Easier sessions, a lower heart rate on a familiar workout, or more time in a lower colour at the same pace are not reasons to change the maximum. They are the expected effects of training.
Thresholds need a separate check. Repeating the talk test and noting the heart rate at the last comfortable sentence tracks where steady work tops out. The training studies above ran for 12 to 20 weeks, so a recheck after a block of about that length is a reasonable interval for newer members. Trained members are likely to see smaller changes.
Key points
- Leave the stored maximum alone unless a credible reading exceeds it, an age-based estimate is several years old, or medication changes.
- Measure progress at a fixed workload. A lower heart rate at the same pace or power shows improved fitness more clearly than any change in zones.
- Ignore single-session differences of about 5 beats per minute and look for a consistent change across several sessions in similar conditions.
- Recheck the first threshold after a training block, especially for newer members, whose thresholds can move the most.
- Expect more output in the same colour as fitness improves, rather than a different colour at the same output.
Sources
- Tanaka H, Monahan KD, Seals DR. Age-predicted maximal heart rate revisited. Journal of the American College of Cardiology, 2001.
- Gellish RL, Goslin BR, Olson RE, et al. Longitudinal modeling of the relationship between age and maximal heart rate. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2007.
- Zavorsky GS. Evidence and possible mechanisms of altered maximum heart rate with endurance training and tapering. Sports Medicine, 2000.
- Wilmore JH, Stanforth PR, Gagnon J, et al. Heart rate and blood pressure changes with endurance training: the HERITAGE Family Study. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 2001.
- Hurley BF, Hagberg JM, Allen WK, et al. Effect of training on blood lactate levels during submaximal exercise. Journal of Applied Physiology, 1984.
- Londeree BR. Effect of training on lactate/ventilatory thresholds: a meta-analysis. Medicine & Science in Sports & Exercise, 1997.
- Lamberts RP, Lemmink KA, Durandt JJ, Lambert MI. Variation in heart rate during submaximal exercise: implications for monitoring training. Journal of Strength and Conditioning Research, 2004.
Heart rate is a training signal, not medical advice. Anyone who takes medication that affects heart rate, or has a heart condition, should agree on intensity guidance with their doctor.