Sport & Performance

Detraining: how quickly fitness fades during a break, and how little training maintains it

Detraining is the partial or complete loss of training adaptations after training stops or is sharply reduced. Aerobic fitness declines first and fastest: in highly trained endurance athletes, maximal oxygen uptake fell by about 7% in three weeks without training. Strength fades more slowly, especially in younger adults. Much less training is needed to keep fitness than to build it. In the available studies, two sessions a week for endurance and one strength session a week maintained most adaptations in younger adults for several months, provided the intensity of those sessions stayed the same.

What is lost first when training stops

The clearest description of the time course comes from a 1984 study by Coyle and colleagues, who followed seven endurance-trained athletes for 84 days after they stopped training. Their VO₂max, the maximum rate at which the body can take up and use oxygen, fell 7% in the first 21 days. It kept falling until about day 56 and then stabilised 16% below the trained value.

The two phases had different causes. The early drop matched a fall in stroke volume, the amount of blood the heart pumps with each beat, which returned to the level of untrained people within the early weeks. The later drop matched a smaller arterial–venous oxygen difference, which describes how much oxygen the muscles extract from the blood. Oxidative enzymes in the muscle declined with a half-time of about 12 days.

Not everything reversed. Capillary density in the muscle did not decline, and after 84 days the athletes still had a higher VO₂max than sedentary people who had never trained.

As an illustration of these average figures, an athlete with a VO₂max of 50 ml/kg/min would be at about 46.5 after three weeks off and about 42 after eight weeks. These are group averages from seven well-trained athletes, not predictions for an individual.

Strength and muscle size fade more slowly

A 2013 meta-analysis by Bosquet and colleagues pooled 103 studies of people who stopped resistance training. Stopping reduced submaximal strength, maximal force and maximal power, and the losses grew with the length of the break. They were larger in adults over 65, and maximal force and power fell more in previously inactive people than in recreational athletes.

The decline is often smaller than people expect. In a trial by Bickel and colleagues, 70 adults aged 20–35 or 60–75 lifted three days a week for 16 weeks and were then assigned to stop entirely or reduce their weekly dose for 32 weeks. The group that stopped kept most of its strength, with only a slight reduction at the final measurement. The shift in muscle fibre type produced by training, however, reversed in that group.

How little training maintains fitness

Maintaining an adaptation needs much less work than creating it. In Hickson and Rosenkoetter's 1981 study, young adults trained at high intensity six days a week for ten weeks, then cut to four or two days a week for 15 weeks. Both groups kept their VO₂max at the trained level throughout.

A 2021 review by Spiering and colleagues collected these maintenance studies. In general populations, endurance performance was maintained for up to 15 weeks with as few as two sessions a week, or with volume reduced by 33–66%, which meant sessions as short as 13–26 minutes. Strength and muscle size in younger adults were maintained for up to 32 weeks with one strength session a week and one set per exercise. Older adults may need up to two sessions a week and two to three sets per exercise to keep muscle size. In the Bickel trial, both reduced doses preserved muscle growth in the younger group, but not in the older group.

Why intensity is the variable to keep

The reduced-frequency studies kept the effort of each session unchanged. When Hickson and colleagues reduced intensity instead, keeping frequency and duration the same, VO₂max was not maintained, and a two-thirds reduction lost more than a one-third reduction. Endurance over about five minutes held up in the one-third group, but long endurance fell by 21% in that group (from 184 to 145 minutes to exhaustion) and by 30% in the two-thirds group.

Two practical points follow. First, the cardiac and muscular adaptations depend on regularly exposing the body to high workloads. A shorter session that still includes hard work keeps that signal, while the same time spent at easy intensity does not. Second, in that study a five-minute test looked stable while long-duration endurance declined. For hybrid races and other events lasting an hour or more, a good short effort does not prove that race endurance has been kept.

Using heart rate to check the intensity

In the endurance studies, intensity was defined by exercising heart rate. That makes heart rate a practical check during a reduced week. If the hard intervals of a shortened session reach the heart-rate zones they normally reach, the key stimulus is probably intact. On the Pulz8 board, a coach can check whether a member's intervals reach the colours they usually reach, rather than comparing them with the rest of the class.

Heart rate lags behind effort at the start of each interval, so very short intervals may end before heart rate reflects their intensity. Heat, dehydration, poor sleep and illness can raise heart rate at a given workload. Read the trace alongside perceived effort and the work completed, such as pace or watts.

Example: a maintenance week

The table below illustrates one way to reduce a typical week during travel or a busy month. It is an example based on the study doses above, not an individual prescription. It combines fewer and shorter sessions, a combination the studies did not test directly.

Usual week Maintenance week
Interval or conditioning sessions 3 classes of 50 minutes 2 sessions of 25 minutes, with the intervals at their usual heart-rate zone
Strength sessions 2 sessions, 3 sets per exercise 1 session, 1–2 sets per exercise at the usual load
Approximate weekly time 250 minutes 80 minutes

An adult over 65, or anyone mainly concerned with keeping muscle mass, would keep two strength sessions with two to three sets.

Limits of the evidence

The core studies are small and old. Hickson's participants had trained for only ten weeks before reducing their training, and adaptations built over years may behave differently. Spiering's review states that there are insufficient data for specific recommendations for athletes, and none of these studies tested hybrid or HYROX athletes. The maintenance periods also have limits: 15 weeks for endurance and 32 weeks for strength are the longest durations tested.

Key points

  1. Expect aerobic fitness to decline first, by about 7% in three weeks without any training in trained athletes.
  2. Keep at least two endurance sessions a week during a busy period, and shorten sessions rather than skip them.
  3. Protect the intensity of those sessions, because reducing effort cost fitness even when total time stayed the same.
  4. Keep one strength session a week with heavy relative loads, and two sessions with more sets for older adults.
  5. Check hard intervals against a member's usual heart-rate zones, allowing for heart-rate lag, heat and fatigue.
  6. Judge race endurance with longer efforts, since a short test can hide a loss of long-duration endurance.

Sources


Heart rate is a training signal, not medical advice. If a break from training was caused by illness, injury or a heart condition, ask a doctor or physiotherapist how and when to return.

See your own zones live. Pulz8 is free for individuals.

← All articles Start free