Group Training Culture

Music in group classes: how tempo and volume change effort, and how to choose a playlist

Music during exercise has small, consistent effects. It makes exercise feel more pleasant, lowers perceived effort at a given workload and modestly improves performance, but it showed no reliable effect on heart rate. Faster music is linked to larger performance benefits, with preferences topping out around 135 to 140 beats per minute. Volume behaves differently. Above a certain level, louder music did not make a class feel harder, and many classes run loud enough to put hearing at risk.

What music changes, and by how much

The largest summary of the research is a 2020 meta-analysis of 139 studies by Terry and colleagues, with 3,599 participants. It reports a standardised effect size (Hedges' g), which expresses the difference between conditions relative to the spread of the data. About 0.2 is conventionally called small and about 0.5 moderate.

Outcome Effect of music (g)
Pleasure during exercise 0.48
Physical performance 0.31
Lower perceived exertion 0.22
Lower oxygen use at a given workload 0.15
Heart rate 0.07, not statistically significant

The authors flag possible publication bias for performance, so that effect may be slightly smaller. Benefits were larger in exercise than in competitive sport, and untrained participants tended to benefit more than trained ones, though few studies compared them directly.

The heart-rate result matters for coaching. Music can make a hard block feel easier without changing the physiological load, so a tile on the heart-rate board stays orange through a favourite track even when the member says the effort feels fine.

Why music has these effects

Distraction is the main explanation for lower perceived exertion: music competes with fatigue signals for attention. Fast, loud, rhythmic music also raises arousal, a state of alertness that suits demanding work and works against a calm cool-down.

The third mechanism is auditory-motor synchronisation, moving in time with the beat. Music is called synchronous when people deliberately match their movement to it, and asynchronous when it plays in the background. In a study of 10 untrained men cycling at 65 revolutions per minute, oxygen uptake was lower with music matched to the pedalling rate (1.80 litres per minute) than with slightly slower music (1.94 litres per minute). Heart rate and perceived exertion did not differ. A later study of 23 recreationally active men found no difference in oxygen uptake, although synchronous music lowered leg discomfort compared with no music. The efficiency benefit is therefore uncertain, and in the meta-analysis synchronous music did not significantly outperform background music.

Tempo: what people prefer as effort rises

Tempo is the speed of the music in beats per minute (bpm), unrelated to heart rate despite the shared unit. In the meta-analysis, music faster than 120 bpm was linked to a larger performance benefit (g = 0.38) than slower music (g = 0.21).

A 2011 study of 28 active students measured preferred tempo during cycling at 40% to 90% of heart-rate reserve, the range between resting and maximum heart rate. Slow music (95–100 bpm) was not preferred at any intensity. As intensity rose, preference for fast music (135–140 bpm) increased relative to medium (115–120 bpm) and very fast (155–160 bpm) music. Faster is not always better, and because the participants were young and active, the bands are a guide rather than a rule.

Music during all-out intervals

During very hard efforts, signals from the body crowd out the music, and the drop in perceived exertion often disappears. In a study of 20 moderately active adults doing four 30-second all-out cycling sprints, self-selected music raised peak and mean power and made the session more enjoyable, while perceived exertion did not change.

A 2026 meta-analysis of 21 studies on music during high-intensity, short-duration exercise linked music to more pleasant feelings and more repetitions, but its effect on peak power and sprint performance was uncertain. The certainty of evidence was low or very low for every outcome. For short, maximal intervals, music is best treated as a way to make hard work more tolerable, not as a reliable performance aid.

Volume and hearing

Sound level is measured in decibels on a logarithmic scale, where every 3 dB rise doubles the sound energy. A-weighted levels (dBA) approximate how the ear perceives sound.

Measurements in 100 Australian fitness classes found levels frequently above 90 dBA, with high-intensity classes averaging 93.1 dBA. About 85% of instructors found loud music motivating, while about one fifth of participants found it stressful. A study of 18 one-hour spin classes in the United States compared how many participants reported a high exercise intensity at different sound levels. In the loudest third of classes (98.4–101.0 dBC) it was 71.8%, statistically no different from 67.1% in the middle third (95.7–98.1 dBC). In the quietest third (93.2–95.6 dBC) it was lower, at 48.2%. Volume therefore seems to matter up to a point, after which more decibels add nothing. In total, 25.9% of respondents said they had experienced ringing or muffled hearing after classes. These levels were measured with C-weighting (dBC), which counts more bass, so they are not directly comparable with dBA.

The WHO standard for safe listening venues recommends that audiences be exposed to an average of no more than 100 dBA over any 15 minutes. For workers, NIOSH recommends no more than 85 dBA averaged over 8 hours, with the allowed time halved for every 3 dB above that.

Example calculation for an instructor. Under the NIOSH rule, 85 dBA is allowed for 8 hours, 88 dBA for 4 hours, 91 dBA for 2 hours and 94 dBA for 1 hour. One 60-minute class at the 93.1 dBA average from the Australian data uses most of a day's allowance, and a second class on the same day exceeds it.

A playlist structure for a class

The following illustrates how the evidence translates into a session. It is not a prescription.

Phase Tempo Volume and use
Warm-up 115–125 bpm Moderate, room for coaching cues
Steady rowing, cycling or running Matched to cadence where possible Moderate, invite members to move with the beat
Hard intervals 125–140 bpm Louder, within the limits above
Strength and technical work Less important Background, so cues stay audible
Cool-down Below 100 bpm Quiet

Synchrony needs a steady rhythm. A cadence of 65 pedal revolutions per minute matches a 130 bpm track at two beats per revolution. Lifts and skill work are self-paced, so a beat adds little there.

Key points

  1. Expect small effects: music makes training feel better and may lift output modestly, but it does not change the physiological load.
  2. Pick tempo by phase, with tracks of about 125–140 bpm for hard work and slower music to calm the room.
  3. Use synchrony for rhythmic work such as rowing, cycling and steady running, where moving with the beat may reduce discomfort.
  4. Turn the volume down from the loudest settings, because the loudest classes did not feel more intense than moderately loud ones, and instructors accumulate exposure across classes.
  5. Read the board, not the mood, because music can lower perceived effort while heart rate stays the same.

Sources


Heart rate is a training signal, not medical advice. Ringing in the ears or muffled hearing that persists after a class needs a hearing assessment.

See your own zones live. Pulz8 is free for individuals.

← All articles Start free